Mechanical performance validated with BAAT Medical

Medical Device mechanical testing & sample size determination – Part one

Medical Device Mechanical Evaluation: Why Sample Size Matters

When developing a medical device, pre-clinical testing is critical to quantify and qualify product performance. At BAAT Medical, we recommend testing early and often during the design process through medical device prototyping. Moreover, early testing provides insights into manufacturing challenges and identifies design issues before costly verification testing begins.

Why Early Testing Matters

The ultimate goal of early evaluation is simple: ensure that verification testing for medical device submissions meets regulatory requirements without surprises. Therefore, testing early helps avoid costly re-testing and delays.

To succeed, you must answer five key questions:

  • Where to test?
  • When to test?
  • What to test?
  • How to test?
  • How many samples to test?

This article focuses on the last question sample size and why it matters for mechanical evaluation.

Mechanical Evaluation: Feasibility

Early design testing, often called feasibility testing, helps you understand your device. In fact, sample sizes should allow engineers to confirm design choices. A simple rationale might explain why one prototype is enough to assess a working principle.

If tests are destructive, consider testing only critical parts instead of the entire prototype. Additionally, start with Finite Element Analysis (FEA) to predict performance and confirm results with one or two samples.

Although using fewer samples seems cost-effective, quantifying variability is essential. For example, 3D-printed devices vary by location on the build plate and material composition. Consequently, collecting samples from multiple batches helps identify performance variations early.

Mechanical Evaluation: Verification

Verification testing provides documented evidence that performance requirements are met. Therefore, sample size rationales must justify why the chosen number is appropriate.

Standards like ASTM or ISO often include sample size guidelines. If not, use statistical techniques based on predicted performance and accuracy requirements. As a result, accurate feasibility data makes verification testing easier and prevents additional testing.

Partner with BAAT Medical

When planning mechanical evaluation, someone will ask: How many samples do we need? The correct answer is: It depends. Regulatory authorities, including Notified Bodies and the FDA, expect a clear rationale for sample size selection.

Frustrating as it may be, “it depends” is the correct answer when setting up your medical device project. In fact, authorities (such as Notified Bodies and the FDA) will expect you to justify the selected sample size number in a rationale when it comes to verification testing.

BAAT Medical helps you test early and often to avoid surprises during verification. Our in-house test facility, subject matter experts, and network of certified labs ensure a first-time-right approach. Ultimately, our goal is to design safe, effective devices that meet global compliance standards.

Read More Articles

More from BAAT Medical